de Grood is asking the Court docket of Enchantment to grant him an absolute discharge, which might free him from assessment board supervision

Article content material

A brand new authorized submitting from a person discovered not criminally chargeable for a lethal mass stabbing is alleging “political interference” by Alberta’s former justice minister within the province’s psychological well being assessment board.

Commercial 2

Article content material

The allegation is available in an Alberta Court docket of Enchantment transient filed Thursday by Matthew de Grood, who killed 5 folks at a Calgary home get together in 2014.

Article content material

In a 2016 courtroom choice met with widespread public outcry, de Grood was discovered not criminally accountable (NCR) for the killings on account of his undiagnosed schizophrenia. He was positioned in a psychological hospital underneath the supervision of the Alberta Overview Board, which makes launch choices relating to folks discovered NCR.

In 2019, the board permitted de Grood to reside in an Edmonton group dwelling, which was met with extra backlash from victims’ households. Two days later, then-UCP justice minister Doug Schweitzer weighed in, acknowledging folks have been “pissed off and disturbed by this choice” and saying he could be “formally requesting that Alberta’s Overview Board guarantee a most attainable function for victims to be a part of the listening to course of and advocating that Ottawa conduct a assessment of requirements of launch.”

Commercial 3

Article content material

de Grood’s Thursday submitting is an enchantment of the board’s 2022 choice to proceed confining him to the group dwelling. It argues de Grood is now not a “important risk” to the general public, and accuses Schweitzer of immediately recruiting board members with comparable partisan leanings following the resignation of the chair who oversaw the 2019 choice.

“The appellant contends that the justice minister’s feedback and his direct recruitment of sure people to the assessment board has created a fear of bias that affected the equity of his 2022 annual assessment,” lawyer Jacqueline Petrie argues within the submitting.

“He asserts that the assessment board, and extra immediately the chair of his listening to, didn’t deal with him in an neutral and procedurally honest method, and the disposition the board made was not reflective of the particular danger he poses however slightly is the results of political interference and public stress to not discharge him or grant him the privileges he seeks.”

Commercial 4

Article content material

de Grood is asking the Court docket of Enchantment to grant him an absolute discharge, which might free him from assessment board supervision.

Lawyer Jacqueline Petrie, seen in a 2021 file photo.
Lawyer Jacqueline Petrie, seen in a 2021 file photograph. Picture by Ian Kucerak /Postmedia

Illuminati, reincarnation and vampires

de Grood was 22 when he fatally stabbed Kaitlin Perras, Lawrence Hong, Jordan Segura, Zackariah Rathwell and Joshua Hunter at an end-of-semester home get together close to the College of Calgary on April 14, 2014. A current science graduate, de Grood had been performing unusually for a number of months, turning into obsessive about matters together with the Illuminati and reincarnation. The night time of the killings, de Grood handed a good friend a clove of garlic, telling him the world was ending and that it will shield him from vampires.

Because the get together wound down, de Grood grabbed a kitchen knife and commenced attacking friends.

Commercial 5

Article content material

After his arrest, de Grood was hospitalized on the Southern Alberta Forensic Psychiatry Centre, the place he was first recognized with schizophrenia and medicated with an anti-psychotic. He ultimately confronted 5 counts of first-degree homicide however was discovered not criminally accountable by Justice Eric Macklin in 2016. He was transferred to Alberta Hospital Edmonton in 2018 over issues in regards to the “poisonous group surroundings” in Calgary.

Like its counterparts throughout Canada, the Alberta Overview Board is made up of provincially appointed attorneys, psychiatrists and group members tasked with balancing the safety of the general public with the rights of NCR sufferers, whose circumstances are heard at the very least every year with enter from medical professionals.

Commercial 6

Article content material

By legislation, NCR sufferers are entitled to the least restrictive circumstances suitable with public security. Boards can select to maintain a affected person “full warrant,” in a psychological hospital or a gaggle dwelling; grant a conditional discharge, permitting them to reside underneath supervision in the neighborhood; or an absolute discharge, releasing them from the board’s authority completely.

Former Alberta justice minister Doug Schweitzer, left, and Alberta Review Board member Gerald Chipeur.
Former Alberta justice minister Doug Schweitzer, left, and Alberta Overview Board member Gerald Chipeur.

‘Arbiters … recruited by the provincial authorities’

The Alberta Overview Board underwent a shake-up following the 2019 de Grood choice, with chairwoman Jill Taylor resigning within the wake of Schweitzer’s feedback.

In response, Schweitzer mentioned Taylor had been appointed by the NDP on the “eve of an election,” and mentioned he would use the chance to “reset” the board and provides a much bigger function to victims’ households.

Commercial 7

Article content material

Different board positions have been subsequently stuffed by members with conservative leanings, Petrie argues, such that an observer would possibly conclude her shopper was dealing with “arbiters who have been recruited by the provincial authorities for the categorical goal of making certain he isn’t discharged or granted additional privileges.”

Petrie’s submitting takes specific difficulty with Calgary lawyer Gerald Chipeur, the chairman of de Grood’s 2022 listening to, whose “procedural rulings have been punitive as regards the appellant,” and “overwhelmingly favoured the victims’ households.”

Petrie famous that on the time Chipeur was making these rulings, media stories indicated he was travelling with then-premier Jason Kenney. 

Commercial 8

Article content material

Petrie argued Chipeur ought to have recused himself due to his “obvious lack of independence and impartiality due to an in depth relationship with the federal government, most immediately the premier, whose justice minister had immediately recruited (him) and publicly expressed an opinion in regards to the appellant and needed to see the requirements of launch tightened and victims given a most function at hearings, which in the end was the impact of Mr. Chipeur’s rulings.”

Chipeur remained on the panel, which concluded de Grood ought to stay underneath full warrant. de Grood’s physician had rated him a low danger to reoffend however advisable he stay dedicated on the group dwelling to permit the remedy crew to raised perceive his “inside world.” Petrie took difficulty with that discovering and mentioned the board misapplied the authorized check for committal.

The Court docket of Enchantment listening to is about for March 28, with a reply transient from the Crown due Feb. 28. Schweitzer held the justice portfolio till August 2020, when Kaycee Madu was elevated to the function. Schweitzer resigned his MLA seat final fall and now works for Deloitte as a senior adviser.

[email protected]

Commercial 1


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail when you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra info and particulars on the best way to alter your e-mail settings.